Past Worthy High Priestess
| Name | Year | Status | Theme |
| Linda Horvath | 2009 | Cougar/Angels/GI Joe | |
| Clara Wert | 2008 | Sunflower/ Teapots/Teddybears | |
| RaeAnn Copsey | 2007 | Scooby Doo | |
| Nancy O'Neill | 2/2007to3/2007 | step in | Angel/Motorcycles/Pink Roses |
| Carma Bell | 3/2006to2/2007 | Deceased//Step out of line | Angel/Motorcycles/Pink Roses |
| Kandice Paszkowski | 2005 | Snow Owl /Trains | |
| Kellye Valentine | 2004 | Cats /Rooster | |
| Clara Wert | 2003 | Sunflower/ Teapots | |
| Dolores Schmidt | 2002 | Dropped | |
| Linda Kniss-Horvath | 2001 | Suns, Moon, Stars | |
| Joyce Zierdt | 2000 | Time | |
| Linda Kniss-Horvath | 1999 | ||
| Jan Cooke | 1998 | Demitted | |
| Alice Gilland | 1997 | ||
| Roberta Yates | 1996 | ||
| Gloria Lake | 1995 | Deceased / Charter Member | |
| Helen Nichols | 1994 | Deceased | |
| Mildred Strahm | 1993 | Deceased | |
| Ruth Wiles | 1992 | Deceased | |
| June Gibson | 1991 | ||
| Betty Lou Ludbrook | 1990 | ||
| Mary Willi | 1989 | Deceased | |
| Betty Lou Ludbrook | 1988 | ||
| Corinne Frost | 1987 | Deceased | |
| Victoria Page | 1986 | Suspended | Bumblebees |
| Helen Nichols | 1985 | Deceased | |
| Beth Rossart | 1984 | ||
| Naomi Stearns | 1984 | Deceased | |
| Bernice Gartin | 1983 | Deceased | |
| Sharalyn Ramm | 1982 | Suspended | |
| Mary Willi | 1981 | Deceased | |
| Sandra Crump | 1980 | Suspended | |
| Lorna Mae Olson | 1979 | Deceased | |
| Betty Lou Ludbrook | 1978 | ||
| Beatrice Frost | 1977 | Deceased | |
| Helen Anderson | 1976 | ||
| Phyllis Elsom | 1975 | Deceased | |
| Floraine Hewitt | 1974 | Deceased | |
| Louisa Eden | 1973 | ||
| Lyndall Mc Callum | 1972 | Deceased | |
| Helen Nichols | 1971 | Deceased | |
| Debbie Bryd | 1970 | Deceased | |
| May Wilding | 1969 | Deceased / Charter Member | |
| Alice Anderson | 1968 | Deceased | |
| Ruth Lamb | 1967 | Deceased | |
| Ida Glenn Jolly | 1966 | Deceased / Charter Member | |
| Bethel Madden | 1965 | Deceased | |
| Marjorie Lamprey | 1964 | Deceased /Demitted | |
| Lavina Kessler | 1963 | Deceased | |
| Frances Frost | 1962 | Deceased / Charter Member | |
| Edna Bolman | 1961 | Deceased | |
| Bertha Sperry | 1960 | Deceased / Charter Member | |
| Helen Mc Kinnon | 1959 | Deceased | |
| Lydia Mc Kay | 1958 | Deceased / Charter Member | |
| Dorothy Young | 1957 | Deceased / Charter Member | |
| Helen Harle | 1956 | Deceased / Charter Member | |
| Laura Ineson | 1955 | Deceased | |
| Genevieve Thorlakson | 1954 | Deceased | |
| Alma Fox | 1953 | Deceased / Charter Member | |
| Faye Walker | 1952 | Deceased /Demitted | |
| Reland Jungquist | 1951 | Deceased / Charter Member | |
| Ella Wazny Hubbard | 1950 | Deceased /Demitted | |
| Pansy King | 1949 | Deceased / Charter Member | |
| Ruth Thorsen | 1948 | Deceased / Charter Member |
