| 1867 James K. Harmison | 1868 J.K. Harmison/Abram Neff |
| 1869 Abram Neff | 1870 Abram Neff |
| 1871 Albert W. Birch | 1872 Albert W. Birch |
| 1873 Abram Neff | 1874 George W. Cline |
| 1875 George W. Cline | 1876 John A. Reichard |
| 1877 John A. Reichard | 1878 John G. Moss |
| 1879 John G. Moss | 1880 John G. Moss |
| 1881 John G. Moss | 1882 Richard Jayne |
| 1883 Richard Jayne | 1884 John G. Moss |
| 1885 Richard Jayne | 1886 Abram Neff |
| 1887 Richard Jayne | 1888 P. W. Gallager |
| 1889 Richard Jayne | 1890 James Cruisen |
| 1891 James Cruisen | 1892 F. M. Mosher Jr. |
| 1893 F. M. Mosher Jr. | 1894 F. M. Mosher Jr. |
| 1895 F. M. Mosher Jr. | 1896 F. M. Mosher Jr. |
| 1897 George M. Heller | 1898 George M. Heller |
| 1899 George Nelson | 1900 F. H. Cole |
| 1901 F. M. Mosher Jr. | 1902 F. M. Mosher Jr. |
| 1903 S. C. Duffie | 1904 George M. Heller |
| 1905 George M. Heller | 1906 C. L Fink |
| 1907 C. L Fink | 1908 Fred Palin Sr. |
| 1909 George M. Heller | 1910 C. L Fink |
| 1911 C. L Fink | 1912 C. L Fink |
| 1913 Guy King | 1914 F. H. Cole |
| 1915 Richard Jayne | 1916 F. H. Cole |
| 1917 William Penn | 1918 C. M. Ewan |
| 1919 O. B. Stockbarger | 1920 F. R. Snively |
| 1921 E. P. Evans | 1922 W. S. Krout |
| 1923 W. S. Krout | 1924 J. G. Ewan |
| 1925 W. S. Krout | 1926 Harry Clayberg |
| 1927 D. W. Clayberg | 1928 D. C. Clayberg |
| 1929 Jack Bath | 1930 Starlie Phillips |
| 1931 Ross H. Jones | 1932 D. C. Clayberg |
| 1933 D. W. Clayberg | 1934 Joe Clayberg |
| 1933 D. W. Clayberg | 1934 Joe Clayberg |
| 1935 George E. Ault | 1936 Joe L. Jackson |
| 1937 Russell McComkey | 1940 Franklin C. Marshall |
| 1939 Joe Clayberg | 1938 Maurice W. Turall |
| 1941 Roland Mellott | 1942 George E. Ault |
| 1943 Emil Wheeler | 1944 Ray McAdams |
| 1945 Starlie Phillips | 1946 Virgil Bell |
| 1947 Willis Shoop | 1948 Howard Lucas Phillips |
| 1949 Floyd Beam | 1950 Daniel Clayberg |
| 1951 Oren Clark | 1952 Clinton Weese |
| 1953 John Williams | 1954 James Hart |
| 1955 Raymond H. Hackett | 1956 Ernest William Lasswell |
| 1957 Harry Eugene Jacobus | 1958 James Moore Edards |
| 1959 Alan Lee Deakin | 1960 Francis E. Woody |
| 1961 Francis E. Woody | 1962 Floyd M. Lowary |
| 1963 Charles E. Dilts | 1964 Edward E. Tomkins |
| 1965 Frankin R. Barlett | 1966 William Clore Black |
| 1967 Ronald L. Tarter | 1968 Alfred E. Nelson |
| 1969 Garlord F. Robertson | 1970 Benjimman G. Bishop |
| 1971 Earl E. Weaver | 1972 Paul E. Noble |
| 1973 Marvin D. Hall | 1974 Clyde L. Frederick |
| 1975 David A Hukill | 1976 John F. Zimmerman |
| 1977 Richard L Keener | 1978 John M. Shaw |
| 1979 Mark Hayden Welch | 1980 James W. Welch |
| 1981 Mark E Clayberg | 1982 John L Fafary |
| 1984 Danny D. Orwig | 1983 Terry E. Pigg |
Past Masters of Cuba Lodge
#534
| 1985 Milton A. Murphy | 1986 Robert E. Thomson |
| 1987 Homer Ralph Herink | 1988 Dale A. Henderson |
| 1989 Neale W. Krider | 1990 Geoffrey Lynn Lasswell |
| 1991 Michael Ray Henderson | 1992 Daniel R. Welch |
| 1993 Dennis D. Leezer | 1994 Rob Wilson |
| 1995 Michael Ray Henderson | 1996 Geoffrey Lynn Lasswell |
| 1997 Homer Ralph Herink | 1998 Marvin Ray Henderson |
| 1999 Richard Leezer | 2000 David Allen Corsaw |
| 2001 Ronald Kruzan | |