| Past Masters |
| 1879 | Charles W. Hemisphere | 1880 | Charles W. Hemisphere | 1881 | Charles W. Hemisphere | 1882 | Robert Thome |
| 1883 | Charles M. Sutton | 1884 | Charles M. Sutton | 1885 | Charles M. Sutton | 1886 | James N. Algar |
| 1887 | Nicholas H. Martin | 1888 | Nicholas H. Martin | 1889 | Abraham Jones | 1890 | Charles M. Sutton |
| 1891 | Charles W. McKinnon | 1892 | Robert Thome | 1893 | Robert Thome | 1894 | David Thomas |
| 1895 | David Thomas | 1896 | David Thomas | 1897 | George H.T. Sparling | 1898 | George H.T. Sparling |
| 1899 | Robert Thome | 1900 | Robert Thome | 1901 | Thomas Harries | 1902 | Asel Feek |
| 1903 | Asel Feek | 1904 | Benjamin Ticknor | 1905 | Eustace A. Anderson | 1906 | Peter Hansen |
| 1907 | Joseph H. Feek | 1908 | William Tonkin | 1909 | Benjamin F. Cake | 1910 | Benjamin F. Cake |
| 1911 | Abraham M. Kline | 1912 | Harry Knipe | 1913 | V.W. Talbot | 1914 | Jesse R. Storey |
| 1915 | Carl O. Tvete | 1916 | Carl O. Tvete | 1917 | John W. Harries | 1918 | Evev T. Rees |
| 1919 | Herbert C. Jarvis | 1920 | Joseph C. Howells | 1921 | Lee Monohon | 1922 | John W. Harries |
| 1923 | Ray H. Hansen | 1924 | Bertram A. Tachell | 1925 | Robert Lowery, Jr. | 1926 | Edward E. Wicker |
| 1927 | Jack Browne | 1928 | Robert Lowery, Sr. | 1929 | James Hepden | 1930 | Jesse T. Wilkins |
| 1931 | John D. Mihalcik | 1932 | Frank E. Nichols | 1933 | Howard L. Bennet | 1934 | Wattie M. Rock |
| 1935 | Ross T. Sherlock | 1936 | Arthur G. Nelson | 1937 | Charles M. Dial | 1938 | Frank H. Whitney |
| 1939 | Edward H. Stokes | 1940 | Jay K. Oakes | 1941 | Frank J. Tonkin | 1942 | Andrew N. Holland |
| 1943 | Walter H. Will | 1944 | William H. Watkins | 1945 | Otto Hendrickson | 1946 | E. Ed Swanson |
| 1947 | Steve Drovetto | 1948 | John C. Marty | 1949 | Reginald Ruttan | 1950 | Ernie R. Robertson, Sr, |
| 1951 | A.W. Dimmit | 1952 | Thomas W. Trimm | 1953 | Joseph VanEykersen | 1954 | Jean D. Pidcock |
| 1955 | Avery Garrett, PDD | 1956 | Lesie P.C. Pidcick | 1957 | Eugene A. Mack | 1958 | Hanford T. Hawkins |
| 1959 | Thomas R. Edwards | 1960 | Frank E. Tibbils | 1961 | Arnold M. Hagan | 1962 | William G. Mathison |
| 1963 | Daryl T. Orseth | 1964 | Robert E. Krueger | 1965 | Glen W. Brown | 1966 | Roy E. Fournier |
| 1967 | James O. Wood, PGM | 1968 | William H. Johnson | 1969 | Kenneth I. Michelsen | 1970 | Ralph J. Gabbard |
| 1971 | Jack R. Lewis | 1972 | George Guerin | 1973 | Herman Turley | 1974 | Samuel L. Franklin |
| 1975 | John P. Qualls | 1976 | Harold B. Broomell | 1977 | R. Burton Felt | 1978 | George C. Kagarice |
| 1979 | Richard V. Neglay | 1980 | William L. Cluphf | 1981 | Donald J. Beck | 1982 | Michael R. Sands |
| 1983 | Willis R. Lambert | 1984 | Paul H. Jenkins | 1985 | Alfred L. Butterfield | 1986 | Richard K. Bish |
| 1987 | Earl V. Buckner | 1988 | Gene Miles, PDD | 1989 | Gene E. Gregory | 1990 | Mohammad Yahyavi |
| 1991 | Robert W. Hudson | 1992 | James D. O'Rourke | 1993 | William A. Byers | 1994 | Richard S. "Bud" Cook III |
| 1995 | James R. Inman | 1996 | Douglas G. Edlich | 1997 | Andrew Dean | 1998 | Larry D. Harger |
| 1999 | Willard E. "Gene" Chandler | 2000 | John S. Livie, Jr. | 2001 | James W. Shaw | 2002 | Duane E. Anderson |
| 2003 | William A. Byers | 2004 | Richard K. Bish, PDD | 2005 | Eugene E. "Gene" Gannon | 2006 | David E. Williams |
| 2007 | Roger A. Barnstead | 2008 | 2009 | 2010 | |||
| Affiliated Past Masters | |||||||
| 1918 | James H. Walls | 1932 | Fred J. Ashurst | 1934 | Claude G. Swett | 1955 | Patterson P. Fugitt |
| 1957 | Daniel S. Griffin | 1958 | Orval R. Millard | 1970 | John Ruiz, Jr. | 1971 | Albert L. Gentry |
| 1980 | Melvin G. Daniel | 1981 | Anthony Dean | 1981 | William D. Pressly | 1985 | Frank R. Davidson |
| 1986 | Ralph Enderson | 1991 | Norman F. Dewing, Jr. | 1992 | Robert J. Pratt | 2004 | Roger A. Barnstead |
| Honorary Past Masters | |||||||
| 1969 | Frank A. Jackson | 1970 | Jesse T. Bryan | 1973 | Edwin F. Hiatt | 1975 | Thomas E. James |
| 1983 | Henry Benz | 1990 | Lester Hansen | 1996 | Charles Y. McGarrigle | 2005 | Daniel J. Moss, PDD |
| Honorary Members | |||||||
| 1922 | Robert F. Chester | 1954 | Archie C. Swensen | 1955 | George J. Manfield | 1956 | William B. Swensen |
| Herbert M. Edman, PGM | Reggie W. Hay, PM | 2003 | Billy Adams | ||||